InTraSAL
First proposed for Bangladeshi Bengali (as B-ToBI) in Sameer ud Dowla Khan's 2008 dissertation and later expanded to cover several diverse languages of South Asia, the Intonational Transcription of South Asian Languages (InTraSAL) is a phonological model and annotation system for the intonation of a range of South Asian languages that share several prosodic characteristics.
The model is part of a tradition of prosodic research known as the Autosegmental-Metrical (AM) Model of Intonational Phonology, which has produced intonational models of a wide diversity of languages. Many of these models have ToBI in their name, based on the prosodic annotation system they use.
The most recent publication describing the B-ToBI model is a 2014 chapter of Sun-Ah Jun's Prosodic Typology II, and the most recent description of the larger InTraSAL model comes from a talk at SALA-34. This website will be updated as the model continues to grow and evolve. This version was last updated on 17 April 2019.
Introduction
InTraSAL is the name for both a phonological model of the intonation of South Asian languages and the annotation system used to represent analyzed recordings of speech in these languages. This website attempts to describe both the model and the annotation system simultaneously. Each tonal element is illustrated in an example sound file along with an image of its pitch contour in blue. Below the pitch contour are three transcription tiers:
- The tones tier shows the tonal events, e.g. L*, Ha
- The words tier shows segmentation and transcription of the text, e.g. ca, ḍhallo/Dhallo
- The English tier shows English labels for words and suffixes, e.g. 'tea', 'spill-PST-3'
Below the image of the pitch contour and tiers, a link to the sound file is found on the [recording code], along with a repetition of the words tier transcription and a 'loose English translation' of the utterance.
[A19] ey lokṭa amar gaŷer upor ca ḍhallo. 'This man spilled tea on me.'
About the recordings
InTraSAL is based primarily off of extending the B-ToBI model of Bangladeshi Bengali to other prosodically similar languages of South Asia. For the time being, the current webpage includes only sound files from Bengali, and will include examples of other South Asian languages in future updates.
The recordings included here were all produced by native speakers of Bengali who grew up in Bangladesh (or in a few cases, in India) and later moved to the US or were visiting the US at the time of recording. Recordings were made in the participants' homes in Southern California, between 2006-2007. Most recordings here were made from a prepared script, designed to minimize the appearance of obstruents (which interrupt the tracking of pitch). Recordings with an "S" ("spontaneous") in the middle of the identification code were unscripted; these were collected from speakers "reading" from Frog, Where Are You?, an illustrated children's book with no text.
While the B-ToBI model is primarily based on Bangladeshi Standard Bengali (as spoken by Bangladeshi Americans), it can reasonably be extended to Indian Standard Bengali and nonstandard regional varieties of Bengali. (With adjustments to allow for lexical pitch accent contrasts, it could presumably be extended to Sylheti, Chittagonian, Chakma, Arkani/Rohingya, etc.) Indeed, some participants used their native regional varieties in the unscripted recordings, and these are incorporated into the B-ToBI model.
Publications
InTraSAL is a model in progress, and no published descriptions currently exist. One proceedings paper and two plenary presentations can serve as an initial description, and are included below:
- Khan, SD. 2020. InTraSAL: An intonational model for South Asian languages. Invited talk, IndoPhon, 5 Oct. (youtube)
- Khan, SD. 2020. Building a unified intonational model for South Asian languages: InTraSAL. Colloquium, University of Michigan, 13 Mar.
- Khan, SD (2018). Building a unified intonational model for South Asian languages: InTraSAL. Invited plenary talk, South Asian Languages Analysis Roundtable 34, Konstanz, 19 Jun. (sound files)
- Khan, SD (2016). The intonation of South Asian languages: towards a comparative analysis. Invited plenary talk, Formal Approaches to South Asian Languages 6, Amherst, 12 Mar. (sound files)
- Khan, SD (2016). Rising contours across South Asian languages: towards a comparative intonational phonology. Poster, UCLA Linguistics 50th Anniversary Celebration, 13 Jun.
The B-ToBI model for describing Bengali intonation is better described in the published literature, with selected publications listed below:
- Khan, SD (2014). The intonational phonology of Bangladeshi Standard Bengali. In Sun-Ah Jun (ed.). Prosodic Typology II: the Phonology of Intonation and Phrasing. OUP. (sound files)
- Yu, Kristine M., SD Khan, and Megha Sundara (2014). Intonational phonology in Bengali and English infant-directed speech. Proceedings of Speech Prosody 7. Dublin: Trinity College.
- Hsu, Brian (2014). Variation in Bangla complementizer order at the syntax-prosody interface. 45th Annual Meeting of the North East Linguistic Society: MIT.
Researchers
InTraSAL and B-ToBI build on the work of many linguists around the world, many of whom work in different frameworks. I've included links to just a handful of researchers (in alphabetical order) who study Bengali intonation, some of whom work directly with B-ToBI and some of whom work(ed) on previous models or alternative models of Bengali intonation:
- Tanmoy Bhattacharya (U Delhi): proposes an information-structural model of Bengali intonation in 2008
- Arunima Choudhury (USC): specializes in focus prosody in both Bengali and Hindi
- Shyamal Das (Tripura U): 2001 dissertation describes Tripuri and Kolkata Bengali stress assignment
- Jennifer Fitpatrick-Cole (U Konstanz): co-authored a 1999 paper on emphatic particles with Aditi Lahiri
- Bruce Hayes (UCLA): co-authored "Bengali intonational phonology" in 1991 with Lahiri
- Brian Hsu (USC): uses B-ToBI to investigate the prosodic factors in complementizer order variation
- Sameer ud Dowla Khan (Reed): developed the B-ToBI model and is co-authoring a description of infant-directed intonation with Yu and Sundara
- Aditi Lahiri (Oxford): co-authored "Bengali intonational phonology" in 1991 with Hayes and a 1999 paper on emphatic particles with Fitzpatrick-Cole
- Elisabeth Selkirk (U Mass Amherst): proposes a prosodic model in 2006 with data from Hayes & Lahiri
- Megha Sundara (UCLA): currently co-authoring a B-ToBI description of infant-directed intonation with Yu and Khan
- Hubert Truckenbrodt (ZAS Berlin): 2002 paper provides an OT syntactic account of phrasing with data from Hayes & Lahiri
- Rashad Ullah (Yale): currently using B-ToBI to investigate the focus realization of NPIs and related phenomena in Bengali
- Kristine Yu (U Mass Amherst): currently co-authoring a B-ToBI description of infant-directed intonation with Khan and Sundara
I've also included links to researchers who study the intonation of other South Asian languages:
- Jennifer Cole (Northwestern): Hindi intonation
- Kalyan Das (IIT Guwahati): first instrumental analysis of lexical tone in Boro
- Gisbert Fanselow (U Potsdam)
- Caroline Féry (Goethe-Universität Frankfurt): typological view of South Asian languages
- Amalesh Gope (IIT Guwahati): first instrumental analysis of lexical tone in Sylheti, co-authored with Mahanta in 2014
- Hans Henrich Hock (U Illinois Urbana-Champaign): overview of prosodic systems, historical prosody
- Sarmad Hussain (Center for Language Engineering): Urdu intonation
- Frank Kügler (Goethe-Universität Frankfurt)
- Shakuntala Mahanta (IIT Guwahati): first instrumental analysis of lexical tone in Sylheti, co-authored with Gope in 2014; also an intonational phonological model of focus prosody in Assamese, co-authored with Twaha in 2015
- Asimul Islam Twaha (IIT Guwahati): intonational phonological model of focus prosody in Assamese, co-authored with Mahanta in 2015